Supreme Court justices are not singing the same religious liberty tune during pandemic

This post was originally published on this site

Legal battles over pandemic-era worship gatherings rage on.

Last October’s confirmation of Justice Amy Coney Barrett flipped the U.S. Supreme Court’s script on such questions.

The latest ruling came last Friday night: A 6-3 order stopped California’s ban on indoor worship in most of the nation’s most populous state. But the justices allowed a 25 percent capacity limit to remain.

Perhaps most interestingly, the majority said California can keep prohibiting singing and chanting. For now.

On the singing issue, the justices sang several different tunes:

Chief Justice John Roberts: “The State has concluded … that singing indoors poses a heightened risk of transmitting COVID–19. I see no basis in this record for overriding that aspect of the state public health framework.”

Barrett, joined by Justice Brett Kavanaugh: “Of course, if a chorister can sing in a Hollywood studio but not in her church, California’s regulations cannot be viewed as neutral. But the record is uncertain. … (H)owever, the applicants remain free to show that the singing ban is not generally applicable and to advance their claim accordingly.”

Justice Neil Gorsuch, joined by Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito: “California has sensibly expressed concern that singing may be a particularly potent way to transmit the disease. … But, on further inspection, the singing ban may not be what it first appears. It seems California’s powerful entertainment industry has won an exemption. So, once more, we appear to have a State playing favorites … expending considerable effort to protect lucrative industries (casinos in Nevada; movie studios in California) while denying similar largesse to its faithful.”

Justice Elana Kagan, joined by fellow dissenting Justices Stephen Breyer and Sonia Sotomayor: California’s “restricted activities include attending a worship service or political meeting; going to a lecture, movie, play, or concert; and frequenting a restaurant, winery, or bar. So the activities are both religious and secular — and many of the secular gatherings, too, are constitutionally protected. In all those communal activities, California requires mask wearing and social distancing, and bars indoor singing and chanting, to reduce the risk of COVID transmission.”

After the ruling, some California churches conducted indoor services Sunday, report The Associated Press’ Christopher Weber and the Los Angeles Times’ Alex Wigglesworth and Thomas Curwen.

Meanwhile, a federal judge this week blocked New York state limits on indoor services in response to a November high court order, according to Bloomberg’s Patricia Hurtado.

For more on the reversal of California’s indoor worship ban, see Chelsea Langston Bombino’s analysis for Religion Unplugged.

Power Up: The Week’s Best Reads

1. Ravi Zacharias hid hundreds of pictures of women, abuse during massages and a rape allegation: Christianity Today’s Daniel Silliman and Kate Shellnutt cover the disturbing findings of a four-month investigation into the late Ravi Zacharias, a world-famous Christian apologist.

Silliman’s investigative reporting — previously praised here and here by Weekend Plug-in — sparked the inquiry.

In advance of the report’s release Thursday, Washington Post religion writer Michelle Boorstein delved into how Zacharias “taught his followers to ask tough questions — just not about his sexual conduct.” It’s a must read.

2. Election turmoil splits West Virginia city’s evangelicals: Associated Press religion journalists Luis Andres Henao and Jessie Wardarski have become one of my favorite tag teams.

They’ve produced exceptional, nuanced multimedia packages from Missouri, New York, Pennsylvania and, now, West Virginia. And those are just the ones that I personally recall.

CONTINUE READING: “Supremes Not All Singing The Same Tune On Religious Freedom During Pandemic” by Bobby Ross, Jr., at Religion Unplugged.

Share This Post
Have your say!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>